Now You Can Be a A Patent Examiner!

The U.S. Patent and Trademark Office is trying something innovative to tackle the growing problem of poor quality patents being issued. On May 12, the office will unveil a pilot project that would let the public review pending patent applications online and submit relevant prior art.

The so-called patent peer review project seeks to ensure that patent examiners will have improved access to all available prior art during the patent examination process. It’ll also help the massively overworked examiners by putting applications in front of a lot more eyes.

The project grew out of a paper published by New York Law School’s Beth Simone Noveck. IBM and other tech companies are supporting the initiative by sponsoring community workshops to teach the public about the new system and to gather input. The pilot will only cover patents in the tech industry, and applications will only be reviewed after receiving the patent applicant’s permission.

Commissioner for Patents John Doll will kick off the pilot on Friday during a public briefing from 9:00 a.m. to noon at the agency’s Madison Building in Alexandria, Va. The briefing will provide more information on how the system works and a tutorial on what constitutes prior art. The agency will take public comments and will launch the full magilla in early 2007.

Veteran patent attorney David Ritchie, a partner at Thelen Reid & Priest, calls it an interesting idea but says he suspects that the vast majority of patent applications will still go unnoted by the public.

“With most applications, only the applicants will care,” he wrote in an e-mail. “But for some of the more high-profile patent applications (e.g. the Amazon One-Click Patent) everyone will have an opinion and many will attempt to provide that opinion directly to the examiner.”

“I doubt that even ten applications per year will rise to that level of common public interest, so it shouldn’t have a big effect in the larger picture, but it might keep some mistakes from happening,” he added.

Xenia Kobylarz


3 Responses to “Now You Can Be a A Patent Examiner!”

  1. Rajlakshmi V Nesargi Says:

    Dear Reader,

    I think its a good idea. In this manner we would be able to cover all the gaps present, in terms of issued patents and if left uncited.

    Thank you


  2. Manish Garg Says:

    Yes, this is a good idea, as this will encourage young and future examiners to should the responsibility and filing the gaps created by issuance of many bad patents on account of overload of examiners.

  3. Rajlakshmi Says:

    Dear readers,

    I am all the more for this experiment so that cases of Amazon being applied for reexamination can be avoided.

    Healthcare industries spend a lot on research oriented activities before ultimately filing for a patent and hence this kind of a challenge could really cost them dearly. Having serious prior art search from the patent office could bring down substantial issues.

    Plus people who want to make the area of patent as their career actually get to be in there.

    So all in all, its a good idea, afterall if it doesnt work out successful it can always be recalled. It definitely wont be the case of “too many cooks spoilt the broth”.

    Thank you


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: